Comments on: Why does the prophet have a security detail? https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/ Thought-provoking commentary on life, politics, religion and social issues. Mon, 23 Jun 2008 15:30:09 +0000 hourly 1 By: rick https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-59214 Mon, 23 Jun 2008 15:30:09 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-59214 “we would need to be able to establish whether he exists.”

Precisely. Which reverses the onus of the burden of proof, etc. Rather than arguing from the side requiring the proof you can argue from the side for which proof must be shown.

It’s a device of rhetoric, but useful nonetheless.

]]>
By: Kim Siever https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58981 Sat, 21 Jun 2008 23:17:44 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58981

There are more converts under 18 than any other age so yeah I’d say there is an increase in children or youth.

Assuming that’s true, that doesn’t establish that the majority of converts are under 18 and located in Utah, which is what would have to be the case for your previous assertion to be true.

I understand a strawman argument. ANY arguement that draws attention away from what is the true matter.

That’s a red herring. A prime example of this is your first comment on this thread.

A strawman is when one person misinterprets the argument of another person and then bases his response on that misinterpretation.

[my beliefs are based on] science and reason.

Really? So in which scientific journal can I read empirical evidence that God is imaginary?

Whereas a statement like,”God is irrelevant” holds much the same spirit, but is not a case of belief and is a fact.

I don’t know that it’s that easy to say, Rick. Without being able to reliably determine his existence (or lack thereof), how can one say absolutely (or as fact) that such an existence is irrelevant. I would think that in order for your statement to be fact, we would need to be able to establish whether he exists.

]]>
By: rick https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58973 Sat, 21 Jun 2008 22:09:18 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58973 “your claim that God is imaginary is simply a belief since it is unsubstantiated by evidence. “

Whereas a statement like,”God is irrelevant” holds much the same spirit, but is not a case of belief and is a fact.

The only way to disprove the statement would be to assemble correlations etc. and in the end would be a waste of time.

]]>
By: Benjamin https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58970 Sat, 21 Jun 2008 21:23:04 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58970 There are more converts under 18 than any other age so yeah I’d say there is an increase in children or youth.
I understand a strawman argument. ANY arguement that draws attention away from what is the true matter. You’re beliefs are based on stories and myth, mine science and reason. How is that difficult to understand?

]]>
By: Kim Siever https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58932 Sat, 21 Jun 2008 14:28:35 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58932 I don’t think you understand what a strawman argument is, Benjamin. If you do, perhaps you can show me where I misinterpret your arguement.

I suppose what I would call evidence is more like common sense.

So basically, your claim that God is imaginary is simply a belief since it is unsubstantiated by evidence. Which of course means you are taking an odd position: tearing down others’ beliefs while trying to present your opinions as fact.

so really it’s all in where you are brought up or what religion is crammed into your noodle when you were too young to know the difference.

If that really were the case, the LDS Church would see growth only among children in Utah.

]]>
By: Benjamin https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58914 Sat, 21 Jun 2008 10:52:41 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58914 for some reason my pc wigged out for a few seconds while writing that piece. I meant to say, “least that’s how it is in religions”

]]>
By: Benjamin https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58913 Sat, 21 Jun 2008 10:48:47 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58913 I chose to ignore Kim’s strawman argument. But for the sake of this blog I’ll play along, though before I say anything on this topic, I must tell you that when people are deluded they can create srawmen arguments and not even know it. It’s a defense mechanism. To the topic at hand: “My evidence that God is imaginary.”

I have none. But I also have no evidence that unicorns, mentioned in countless tales of old, aren’t either. I suppose what I would call evidence is more like common sense. Look around and say to yourself, wow, what an unusual number of religions! So many of them are screaming they are the ONLY church (slight cough, gestures toward nearest Mormon) More still, what about the numerous similarities among stories of crucifixtions, rising fromt he dead after several days DEAD, ascending to heaven after rising, all of these things are told in stories long before Jesus is supposedly suppose to have come along.
The world is far grander a place to live in when you think of how fragile the time we have alive is. Besides, why would anyone wanna be watched around the clock by god? or judged by him for things this “god” supposedly made them feel such as lust least that’s how it.
And to be honest with you, had you been born in the middle east what do you think the odds of you being Mormon are or thinking it’s correct….slim to zero, so really it’s all in where you are brought up or what religion is crammed into your noodle when you were too young to know the difference.

]]>
By: Mary Siever https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58793 Fri, 20 Jun 2008 16:25:16 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58793 I’m not waiting for the second coming…I have too much to do now. Ah Benjamin, I feel for you, living among people who you see as deluded. I would suggest you find a new place to live. Honestly, instead of trying to focus on something that you find so negative, why don’t you focus on accentuating the positives in your life and in your beliefs. To focus on the ‘joy’ of your beliefs rather than cutting down something you are obviously so much against? It’s much more productive to build, rather than tear down.

I didn’t say you ‘were’ agitated, only that you seem so. And you haven’t answered Kim’s question. Perhaps you can’t?

]]>
By: Benjamin https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58790 Fri, 20 Jun 2008 16:19:44 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58790 Mary Siever said: :)

But do all those missionaries tell you you are wrong and an idiot because you don’t believe what they believe?

But to what you said about me being agitated– that’s kind of silly to say. I didn’t say anything to imply a shakiness in my beliefs but rather a passsion for them which you misconstrue as agitation. On the other hand yes I am agitated by the many many LDS members around me but that’s only because of where I live. And you clearly think that it’s some stretch of the imagination or me being pious in someway to say that you ALL are wrong but not really. If you saw millions of people with their head buried in dirt you’d think what they were doing was silly and you could clearly see the harm in doing it. Likewise for Mormonism. Besides, the LDS are NOT a major religion, more of a fringe gathering. But I’m done talking with you as you clearly are lost to your delusion . . . and before you say that I too am lost to a delusion, stop and ask youself why my delusion is shared with the vast majority of the world when at least considering the LDS? Mormons are a doomsday religion waiting for the second coming and are wasting their time.

]]>
By: Kim Siever https://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/comment-page-3/#comment-58766 Fri, 20 Jun 2008 11:38:20 +0000 http://www.ourthoughts.ca/2007/05/09/why-does-the-prophet-have-a-security-detail/#comment-58766 By that same token then, Benjamin, I assume you have evidence that God is imaginary.

]]>